Month: February 2022

Alleged theft of government COVID-19 relief funds sparks calls for more oversight

The alleged theft of tens of thousands of dollars in COVID-19 relief funds is triggering calls for improved oversight of pandemic spending.

As disclosed by , as many as 400 e-transfer payments of $200 and $250 were funneled to fake accounts or addresses earlier this year.

A Ministry of Education employee was fired and the Ontario Provincial Police anti-rackets squad has been called in to probe the scheme, which may have netted as much as $100,000.

The province has also retained KPMG to conduct an investigation to determine how much was stolen from the $380-million Support for Families program.

That pandemic measure was introduced by Finance Minister Rod Phillips last spring to help families “offset the cost of buying materials to support their children’s learning while they practiced self-isolation and physical distancing.”

There were payments of $200 for all children up to age 12 and $250 for children or youth with special needs up to age 21. The money was to help parents buy work books, educational apps, and other learning tools.

NDP Leader Andrea Horwath said Monday the alleged theft was “really disappointing.”

“The money was meant for families and children. You have to be able to get money into the hands of people who need it as quickly as possible,” said Horwath.

“People are suffering, families are suffering, kids are suffering, households are suffering,” she said.

“It’s really unfortunate you have folks who take advantage of this situation for their own private financial benefit … it’s really sad and it’s pretty disgraceful.”

But Horwath said the government, which unveiled a record $187 billion budget earlier this month, must keep on top of where money is flowing.

“At the same time you do want to have some sense of accountability,” she said.

Liberal house Leader John Fraser said “it’s something the auditor general should be looking at.”

“When you’re implementing a program so quickly, your risk goes up considerably. So the government needs to have those measures in place,” said Fraser.

“Obviously, this was caught. Fraud does happen,” he said.

Green Leader Mike Schreiner said with unprecedented spending comes the need for increased oversight.

“Whenever government is responding this quickly, there’s always a concern around fraud. Clearly, we need to have the mechanisms in place,” said Schreiner.

“It’s good that this person allegedly has been caught and action has been taken,” he said.

OPP Sgt. Kerry Schmidt has said police “will not comment further to protect the integrity of the investigation.”

“As this is a criminal investigation, we will not speculate as to the likelihood of charges,” said Schmidt.

Attorney General Doug Downey’s office has emphasized that “any abuse of taxpayers dollars is totally unacceptable.”

Phillips, who renewed the popular program in , told the on Friday that “we’re spending historic amounts of money and we need to be very vigilant that dollars are getting to people.”

While the finance minister could not speak to this specific case because it’s before the courts, he noted “it always disappointing when people take advantage of a situation that is meant to help people in a very difficult time.”

Robert Benzie is the Star’s Queen’s Park bureau chief and a reporter covering Ontario politics. Follow him on Twitter:

Disability rights groups decry Ford government ‘secrecy’ about COVID-19 triage guidelines

A coalition of disability rights groups is calling on government to make public the directions they plan to give hospitals about how to decide who should be prioritized for life-saving treatment if intensive care units become overwhelmed with patients.

The call comes after the government’s initial COVID-19 triage protocol — which , but was never officially released — was rescinded after it was .

“We write about a life-and-death issue now facing Ontarians,” reads the , signed by more than 60 organizations and sent Thursday to Ford, Health Minister Christine Elliott and Raymond Cho, the minister responsible for seniors and accessibility.

The letter calls on the province to immediately release the latest recommendations from its Bioethics Table — the government-appointed group of physicians and bioethicists advising the ministry on a number of COVID-related issues — and ensure that any new triage guidelines “respect the constitutional and human rights of all patients, including patients with disabilities.”

The purpose of a triage protocol, which would be invoked only if critical care resources needed to be rationed, is to minimize overall mortality by prioritizing patients with the best chance of survival.

Among the concerns raised by disability advocates about the government’s initial protocol was its inclusion of the Clinical Frailty Scale, a nine-point grading tool they said was inherently discriminatory against people with disabilities and could lead to their exclusion from life-saving treatment.

In their letter, the organizations commend the government for rescinding the initial protocol, but the fact that nothing has taken its place also poses a danger.

“If critical care triage becomes necessary, decisions over who gets refused life-saving critical care would be wrongly left to individual hospitals and doctors without safeguards against the serious danger of arbitrary and discriminatory decisions made because of disability,” the letter reads.

Roberto Lattanzio, executive director of the ARCH Disability Law Centre, said the province needs to ensure that any new policy protects the rights of people with disabilities.

“The pandemic doesn’t give governments a pass on ensuring that human rights and constitutional rights are respected,” he said in an interview. “We’ve been advocating for a framework free of discrimination for eight months now and now we find ourselves in a very similar situation as we did from the outset.”

While the number of active COVID-19 cases in Ontario is nearly three times as high as during the peak of the first wave in the spring, hospitalizations and admissions to intensive care units (ICUs) are actually lower now than they were then. On Wednesday, . On May 1, by comparison, there were more than 1,000 COVID patients in hospital, including 225 in ICUs.

The province in April, increasing the number of ICU beds by nearly 1,500 to a total of 3,504. Roughly half of the province’s ICU beds were occupied as of Dec. 1, according to Critical Care Services Ontario’s daily report.

Last month, , Progressive Conservative MPP Robin Martin confirmed the government had rescinded its initial protocol, which she said was only a draft, and that a “revised framework may be shared … should pandemic conditions deteriorate significantly.”

But, Martin said: “We don’t anticipate getting anywhere near having to use such a protocol.”

David Lepofsky, chair of the Accessibility for Ontarians with Disabilities Act Alliance, said cases have steadily increased since Martin’s assurances, and the lack of action by the government is inexcusable.

“They can’t wait until the day where they need triage and then say, ‘By the way, here are the rules.’ ”

The health ministry ignored specific questions for this story and instead sent a 265-word statement, which says, in part, that the ministry asked the Bioethics Table to “ensure that concerns and perspectives of those representing Indigenous people, Black and racialized communities, persons with disabilities, and others who may be disproportionately affected by critical care triage due to systemic discrimination, are meaningfully considered and reflected in a revised protocol.”

A ministry spokesperson did not respond to a follow-up question asking whether the government intended to make the revised protocol public.

Lattanzio and Lepofsky both decried the government’s lack of transparency about the protocol, a criticism that has also been raised by and .

“What’s the secret?” Lepofsky said. “There is no plausible reason for them to keep secret whatever the Bioethics Table recommended. There’s nothing served in the public interest.”

Brendan Kennedy is a Toronto-based social justice reporter for the Star. Follow him on Twitter:

COVID-19 school-related cases jump by 24 per cent in latest Ontario report

The number of new active cases in public schools across the province has jumped by another 24 per cent from the previous day to a total of 308.

, the province reported 64 more school-related cases — 37 more students were infected for a total of 164; seven more staff members for a total of 44; and 20 more individuals who weren’t identified for a total of 100.

There are 250 schools with an active case, which the province notes is 5.18 per cent of the 4,828 public schools.

Two schools are currently closed — Monsignor Paul Baxter elementary school in Ottawa and in Toronto.

More than 170 students and all staff at Mason Road Junior, near Bellamy Road and Eglinton Avenue East, have been ordered to stay home and isolate while the school is shut this week, Toronto Public Health said in a letter.

Epidemiologists have that the numbers in the schools aren’t a surprise, and that the cases will be proportionate to the amount of COVID that’s in the community. Ontario reported 554 additional cases overall across the province.

Tuesday’s numbers reflect reports from over the weekend and are accurate as of 2 p.m. Monday.

There is a lag between the daily provincial data at 10:30 a.m. and news reports about infections in schools. The provincial data is current as of 2 p.m. the previous work day, and doesn’t indicate where the place of transmission occurred.

The TDSB updates its information on current COVID-19 cases throughout the day . As of 9 a.m. Tuesday, there were 48 TDSB schools with a case — 36 students and 21 staff.

Zena Salem is a breaking news reporter, working out of the Star’s radio room in Toronto. Reach her via email: